In the “Trust Game”, men with more autistic traits were less influenced by their partner’s facial appearance 

By Emma Young

We make all kinds of snap decisions about a person based on their facial appearance. How trustworthy we think they are is one of the most important, as it can have many social and financial consequences, from influencing our decisions about whether to lend someone money to which Airbnb property to book.

However, as the authors of a new study, published in the British Journal of Psychology, note, “Although facial impressions of trustworthiness are formed automatically, they are not especially accurate predictors of trustworthy behaviour.” People who are less susceptible to forming these impressions could, then, be at an advantage. And, as Jasmine Hooper at the University of Western of Australia and colleagues now report, men with high levels of autistic traits fall into this category. 

Earlier work (involving two authors of the new study) already hinted that autism might have a bearing on whether people act on first impressions in a typical way. The researchers found that when they prompted boys diagnosed with autism to judge trustworthiness from photographs, they formed the same kinds of impressions as non-autistic boys, but unlike them, they did not use these judgments in their decision-making in an economic trust game. 

To explore whether higher levels of autistic-like traits, such as increased attention to detail, might also affect the use of first impressions even among the general population, the researchers recruited 46 men without autism, who completed the Autism-Spectrum Quotient (a symptom-based scale which is typically used by clinicians to diagnose autism) and a facial trustworthiness impressions task. The researchers found that, as they predicted, when prompted to make trustworthiness judgements from faces, people with high or low levels of autistic traits made similar judgements. But the next phase of the study showed some important differences between the two groups.

All the participants also took part in an adult version of the economic trust game used in the earlier research with boys, in which they interacted with virtual “partners”, who had been independently rated as looking either trustworthy or untrustworthy. Over a series of trials, these partners were consistently fair or selfish, and crucially this behaviour pattern was not related to their facial appearance. Therefore the best strategy for predicting future behaviour – and making money, because participants could keep their winnings – was for the participants to ignore appearances and focus solely on their partner’s behaviour in previous money allocation trials. 

Again as the researchers predicted, the men with relatively low levels of autistic traits were influenced by how trustworthy or not the partners looked. The men who scored relatively high on the AQ scale were influenced too, but to a significantly lesser extent – they were more influenced by their partners’ actual behaviour. 

Only between 1 and 1.5 per cent of people in the UK are thought to meet the criteria for a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder. However, many other people do not meet the diagnostic criteria for autism but do have relatively high levels of autistic traits – there may therefore be a sizeable subset of people who are able to form trustworthiness judgements based on people’s faces when prompted, but who don’t do this automatically, and also aren’t so inclined to use these judgments in their social decisions (and so are less swayed by potentially misleading facial impressions than the rest of the population). 

As the researchers note, “If facial impressions are not especially accurate predictions of actual trustworthiness, failure to use them to guide trust decisions may actually represent highly rational social behaviour.” 

Should I trust you? Autistic traits predict reduced appearance‐based trust decisions

Emma Young (@EmmaELYoung) is Staff Writer at BPS Research Digest

6 thoughts on “In the “Trust Game”, men with more autistic traits were less influenced by their partner’s facial appearance ”

  1. Almost everyone I know is a cheater, should I disregard the overwhelming evidence and then get harvested by a hypergamous monkey-branching parasite, or should i stick with an evidence based, reasoned statistical approach. That is the autistic perception of trust. Those that trust are usually either cheaters themselves, who don’t care if they get cheated on or people who are either too unobservant or who cannot face the emotional trauma of admitting that any potential partner is likely to have been guilty of infidelity, at some point, so they employ faith, instead of evidentially robust methods in coming to a decision on whether to trust. Most relationships fail and most men and woman are likely keepers of lies, about past or current affairs. In what sense is the autistic person the one with the dysfunctional approach to trust? Haaaaa

    Like

    1. I’m lucky enough to have only trustworthy friends. None of my friends would cheat on their boyfriends/girlfriends/wives/husbands. If they did, they would tell me about it because i’m super unjudgemental, but they never would. If you want to have a trustworthy person, I think it might be more likely to find them among highly emphatic people who have a lot of patience/determination, because if they are highly emphatic they wouldn’t want to hurt their partner and if they had patience/determination, then they would also have the tools required to resist any temptation of cheating when it presents itself. Even higher likelihood of finding faithful people is if you look among asexuals since they won’t have any temptation to start with.

      But there are of course lots of people who aren’t emphatic, determined or asexual but are still faithful. Many of my friends belong in this category as well. 😀

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s